David went into hospital for a routine surgical procedure on his left side. He'd prepared for it, discussed the details with his consultant, and felt confident he was in safe hands. But when he came round from surgery, something didn't feel right. The incision was in the wrong place—the surgeon had operated on his right side instead.
When David raised his concerns immediately, he expected a straightforward acknowledgement and explanation. Instead, the hospital's response was defensive. They suggested that what had happened was simply one of the known risks he'd been warned about before surgery. David found this deeply frustrating. He knew the difference between an accepted risk and a fundamental mistake about which side of his body should be treated.
David decided to seek legal advice about his experience. A solicitor helped him gather his medical records and the hospital's own documentation. The clearer the picture became, the harder it was for the hospital to maintain their position. After proceedings were issued, the hospital's lawyers reviewed the evidence carefully. They could no longer credibly defend their position. The hospital admitted full liability for the wrong-site surgery.
The case demonstrates why persistence matters when something goes wrong in your care. Hospitals have a fundamental duty to operate on the correct site—it's not a matter of accepted risk. Sometimes institutions will initially deny responsibility, but proper legal investigation can reveal the truth and lead to the accountability patients deserve.
In Ireland, hospitals and medical professionals have a duty of care to their patients. This includes clear obligations around patient identification and ensuring procedures are carried out on the correct site. Wrong-site surgery is considered a breach of this duty because it represents a failure in basic safety procedures, not an unavoidable medical risk. When a patient can show that a healthcare provider failed to meet the standard of care a reasonable professional would have provided in similar circumstances, and that this failure caused harm, they may have grounds for a medical negligence claim. The burden of proof is on the patient to demonstrate negligence, but when hospitals are unable to explain how such an error occurred, their admissions of liability often follow.
Medical negligence claims in Ireland must generally be brought within three years of the date you became aware of the injury and its connection to medical negligence. For some cases involving children or people lacking mental capacity, different time limits may apply. Waiting too long can mean losing your right to claim. If you believe you've experienced medical negligence, speak with a solicitor as soon as possible to understand your time frame and protect your rights.
Tell Sarah what happened. She will explain your options and match you with the right solicitor in your county — free.