Declan's Story
Declan was 52 when he went into a private hospital in Limerick for what his surgeon described as routine surgery. He had been suffering from a condition that was affecting his mobility, and surgery was meant to fix it. He wasn't overly worried — his consultant had done hundreds of these procedures and came with solid recommendations. The operation went ahead on a Tuesday afternoon.
Within days of leaving hospital, Declan noticed something was wrong. His leg felt numb in places it shouldn't, and he was in pain that felt different from normal post-operative discomfort. He rang the hospital. He was reassured that some numbness could be normal after this type of surgery and that it might settle down over time. Six months passed. Then a year. The numbness didn't improve. In fact, it got worse. Declan couldn't walk properly without a cane, and certain sensations in his leg were completely gone. His quality of life had changed dramatically.
A year and a half after the operation, Declan saw another surgeon for a second opinion. That's when the alarm bells rang. The new consultant examined him thoroughly and then reviewed the operative notes from his original surgery. He told Declan that the nerve damage looked like it had come from how the surgery was performed, not from the operation itself. The surgical technique appeared to have been at fault. This wasn't an unavoidable risk — it was an error.
Declan decided to pursue a claim. He contacted eSolicitors.ie and was connected with a personal injury solicitor who specialised in medical negligence cases. The solicitor immediately commissioned an independent expert — a surgeon with no connection to the case — to review Declan's medical records and operation notes. That expert's report was damning. It stated clearly that the nerve damage had been caused by poor surgical technique that fell below what would be expected of a reasonably competent surgeon performing this procedure. The technique used was not standard practice and had directly caused Declan's harm.
With expert evidence in hand, the hospital's insurers knew they had a difficult case to defend. Rather than face a trial, they agreed to settle. Declan received a substantial settlement that reflected the permanent nature of his injury, the impact on his working life, and his ongoing pain and reduced mobility. The whole process from first contact with his solicitor to settlement took just over two years.
What the Law Says
In Ireland, every medical practitioner — whether a surgeon, consultant, or GP — owes a legal duty of care to their patients. This means they must treat you with the level of skill and care that a reasonably competent practitioner in their field would provide.
If a doctor or surgeon fails to meet that standard and you suffer harm as a result, you may have grounds for a medical negligence claim. It's not enough to simply have a bad outcome. Medicine carries inherent risks, and patients accept that sometimes things don't go as hoped despite the best efforts. But negligence is different. It's when the doctor has fallen below the standard that could reasonably be expected.
In Declan's case, the expert evidence showed that his surgeon had used a technique that fell below the standard expected of a competent surgeon. This wasn't an unfortunate complication — it was a breach of duty. That breach directly caused his nerve damage. Those are the three key things you need to prove: duty of care existed, it was breached, and the breach caused your harm.
What Declan Was Entitled To
Declan's Settlement Covered:
General damages: Money for his pain, suffering, and loss of amenity (the reduced quality of life). Because the nerve damage was permanent and affected his mobility and everyday activities, this was a significant part of his award.
Special damages: Out-of-pocket costs including medical and physiotherapy expenses, mobility aids, and home modifications he needed because of his reduced mobility.
Loss of earnings: Because his injury affected his ability to work, he received compensation for lost income and reduced earning capacity going forward.
Compensation in medical negligence cases depends heavily on the severity of the injury and how much it affects the person's life. Permanent nerve damage that limits mobility and causes ongoing pain falls into the upper range. Declan's settlement reflected that this was a life-altering injury with permanent consequences.
In Ireland, compensation ranges for medical negligence vary enormously. Minor cases might settle for €30,000 to €50,000. Serious injuries causing significant disability or loss of earning capacity can reach €500,000 or more. Declan's case, involving permanent nerve damage and reduced mobility, settled in the six-figure range — well above the lower end, but not the absolute maximum because he was in his 50s when injured and his remaining working life was shorter than it might have been for a younger person.
⏰ Important: Time Limits Apply
You have two years from the date you became aware of the negligence to issue a claim in Ireland. This is a hard deadline. If you miss it, you lose your right to compensation, no matter how strong your case is. Don't delay if you think you've been harmed by medical negligence. Contact a solicitor as soon as you realise something may have gone wrong.
Sound familiar?
You may have a case too.
Tell Sarah what happened. She will explain your options and match you with the right solicitor in your county — completely free, no obligation.