← Back to The Probate Process in Ireland — Explained

Claire's Story: Finding Agreement When Beneficiaries Disagree

How a family in Limerick resolved a dispute over their father's business

When Claire's father passed away, he left behind a thriving business and a clear will. On paper, everything seemed straightforward — the estate would be divided equally among his three children. But valuing the family business turned out to be far more complicated than anyone expected. The beneficiaries couldn't agree on what it was worth, and the longer they disagreed, the more tension built between them. Claire watched her siblings become increasingly frustrated, worried that this dispute might damage relationships that had always been close.

Rather than let matters escalate to court, Claire's solicitor suggested bringing in a mediator to help the family reach a fair valuation. This independent professional would listen to each beneficiary's concerns and help them understand the different valuations that had been put forward. It felt like a big step, but Claire and her siblings were willing to try it. Over several meetings, the mediator helped them look past the numbers and talk about what mattered most — keeping their family intact while settling their father's estate fairly.

The process wasn't quick, but it worked. With the mediator's help, the beneficiaries gradually came to trust the valuation approach being used. They understood the reasoning behind it and felt heard throughout the discussion. Within a few months, they had reached an agreement they could all live with. The business was valued, the estate was distributed, and Claire's family moved forward together. What could have been a bitter legal battle became a managed disagreement with a sensible outcome.

What the Law Says

When beneficiaries cannot agree on how to value assets in an estate — particularly business interests, property, or shareholdings — Irish law allows them to use mediation, independent valuation, or expert determination to reach agreement. These methods are often quicker and less costly than court proceedings. If an estate includes a business, the Personal Representative (executor) has a duty to obtain a fair and accurate valuation, and beneficiaries have the right to question valuations they believe to be unreasonable. Mediation is increasingly recognised as an effective way to resolve such disputes while preserving family relationships.

⏱ Important: Time Limits

Beneficiaries typically have a limited period to raise objections to how an estate is being valued and distributed. Once a Personal Representative distributes the estate, it becomes much harder to challenge their decisions. If you have concerns about how a business asset or other major estate item has been valued, raise them promptly with the executor or their solicitor. Don't wait — take action within weeks, not months.

Free Solicitor Matching

Sound familiar?
You may have a case too.

Tell Sarah what happened. She will explain your options and match you with the right solicitor in your county — free.